As part of our weekly (which have been more like bi-weekly) themes this Summer, I decided to get a stack of Caldecott winner and honor books from the years that everyone in our family was born. This was way fun. The kids always like when we happen to check out a book that "has a medal", so the concentrated effort to focus just on "medal" books was exciting. We compared and contrasted styles and picked our favorites from each stack. We found books we otherwise may have never checked out. This was one of the more worthwhile stacks fo books we've had of late. Without further ado:
The Girl Who Loved Wild Horses (1979) - This book was odd. At the end Gemma was like, "so wait, people can turn into horses?" Um, no. But, the illustrations were really cool in a Native American-y sort of way, and it gave us an opportunity to talk about the cultural traditions and belief systems of other peoples. We even talked a bit about St. Kateri and missionaries who spread Christianity to the Native Americans. So albeit a strange story, I'd say it was a win.
Knuffle Bunny Too: A Case of Mistaken Identity (2008) - It was sheer providence that this book was from the year Gemma was born. We have read it dozens of times over the years, and Knuffle Bunny is probably Gemma's favorite Mo Willems character. I love love the illustrations. The morphing of real-life photographs and Willem's cartoony caricatures is just oh so great.
All The World (2010) - This one was beautiful, but I think its beauty was mainly lost on the kids. But that's OK, I enjoyed it. I love it when an author can make something rhyme yet still have such charm and depth in meaning.
Ox-Cart Man (1980) - This is another perennial favorite around here, and was probably my fan-fave from our first stack of five. I like the simplicity, the attention to detail, Barbara Cooney's illustrations. A good book.
A Ball For Daisy (2012) - Cute cute cute. For the longest time (OK, up until we read this book) I have found picture books with no words to be intimidating. But we really had fun with this one, I think we "read" it four times, with me doing the first reading, then Kolbe and Gemma each took a turn respectively, and then I did one more reading because Gemma insisted I didn't "read" the whole thing the first time. Haha. The pictures in this one were so adorable, and did a great job at evoking a wide variety of emotions.
We had to get a few from this year (2015) so we got:

The Adventures of Beekle - The illustrations were cute, the storyline was cute enough. It was completely last on my kids though. I liked this one but didn't think it really fell into that "timeless" category.
Sam and Dave Dig a Hole - This was adorable. Anyone with little boys should read this book, very clever.
Our next stack of five books proved to be interesting as well. I tell you though, if our two 1979 titles were any indication of picture books in the 1970s I think I'll stay away from that decade. I mean, I realize it was the seventies and everything, but wow... I am going to have to dig a bit further in that decade now just because I'm curious............ OK, I suppose a decade that gave us Sylvester and the Magic Pebble, Why Mosquitos Buzz in People's Ears, It Could Always Be Worse and Peter Spier's Noah's Ark can't be all bad. But even so, I am going to declare that 1979 was not a stellar year.
The Way to Start A Day (1979) - This was nice, and very "global", but still just not great (IMHO). Maybe my kids are too literal or haven't been exposed to enough (maybe that's why they didn't get Beekle...) The illustrations were very reminiscent of Wild Horses I thought, and the text was just a little odd for my liking.
Ben's Trumpet (1980) - What a difference a year makes. Maybe I'm just partial, but this was great! From the story to the illustations. I loved it. It also provided a good excuse to to listen to some jazz.
First the Egg (2008) - Gemma, aptly, really liked this one, and read it to us. In fact, Kolbe even had fun helping to "read" this one, due to its simple predictability. The cut-outs in the pages were so creatively done. But it still left you scratching your head thinking, "which does come first???..."

The Lion and the Mouse (2010) - Another worldess book (for the most part), but the kids knew this story from our book of Aesop's fables. Kolbe really took a liking to both wordless books in our pile (so much so that I've requested several more). The illustrations in this one were stunning.
Blackout (2012) - This was good, not great. Nice message, but I didn't think there was anything particularly memorable about it.
What are your favorite Caldecott Award books?
We had to get a few from this year (2015) so we got:

The Adventures of Beekle - The illustrations were cute, the storyline was cute enough. It was completely last on my kids though. I liked this one but didn't think it really fell into that "timeless" category.
Sam and Dave Dig a Hole - This was adorable. Anyone with little boys should read this book, very clever.
Our next stack of five books proved to be interesting as well. I tell you though, if our two 1979 titles were any indication of picture books in the 1970s I think I'll stay away from that decade. I mean, I realize it was the seventies and everything, but wow... I am going to have to dig a bit further in that decade now just because I'm curious............ OK, I suppose a decade that gave us Sylvester and the Magic Pebble, Why Mosquitos Buzz in People's Ears, It Could Always Be Worse and Peter Spier's Noah's Ark can't be all bad. But even so, I am going to declare that 1979 was not a stellar year.
The Way to Start A Day (1979) - This was nice, and very "global", but still just not great (IMHO). Maybe my kids are too literal or haven't been exposed to enough (maybe that's why they didn't get Beekle...) The illustrations were very reminiscent of Wild Horses I thought, and the text was just a little odd for my liking.
Ben's Trumpet (1980) - What a difference a year makes. Maybe I'm just partial, but this was great! From the story to the illustations. I loved it. It also provided a good excuse to to listen to some jazz.
First the Egg (2008) - Gemma, aptly, really liked this one, and read it to us. In fact, Kolbe even had fun helping to "read" this one, due to its simple predictability. The cut-outs in the pages were so creatively done. But it still left you scratching your head thinking, "which does come first???..."

The Lion and the Mouse (2010) - Another worldess book (for the most part), but the kids knew this story from our book of Aesop's fables. Kolbe really took a liking to both wordless books in our pile (so much so that I've requested several more). The illustrations in this one were stunning.
Blackout (2012) - This was good, not great. Nice message, but I didn't think there was anything particularly memorable about it.
What are your favorite Caldecott Award books?

